Clinics · Comparison
Alloy vs Midi Health
Both are primarily women’s HRT & menopause providers, so the differences are in consult model, what is bundled, who prescribes, and price.
| Alloy | Midi Health | |
|---|---|---|
| Our score | 10.0 / 10 | 8.3* / 10 |
| Starting price | $49 one-time consult | $250 first visit self-pay |
| Primary service | Women’s HRT & menopause | Women’s HRT & menopause |
| All services | HRT | HRT |
| Consult model | Asynchronous (questionnaire + messaging) | Live video consult |
| Prescriber | MD/DO | MD/DO + NP/PA |
| Labs | Not needed | Unconfirmed |
| Insurance | Cash pay | Accepted |
| Availability | 50 states + DC | 50 states |
| Cancellation | Self-serve online | No subscription to cancel |
| Trustpilot | 4.3 / 5 (4,061 reviews) | 4.1 / 5 (1,740 reviews) |
| Regulatory / legal record | None found | None found |
| Relationship | Independent | Independent |
* Provisional score: one or two criteria could not be verified.
Choose Alloy if…
Cash-pay women who want FDA-approved estradiol and progesterone prescribed by a physician through messaging, with prices visible up front.
- Full per-product prices and the $49 consult fee are published before sign-up
- Physician-only prescribing (menopause-trained, board-certified doctors)
- Available in all 50 states and DC
Choose Midi Health if…
Women with commercial PPO insurance seeking menopause or perimenopause care, including hormone therapy, through video visits.
- In-network with most major PPO insurance plans
- No membership fee; transparent self-pay visit prices ($250 / $150)
- Available in all 50 states
Compare Alloy or Midi Health with any other company in the comparison tool →
Alloy vs Midi Health: common questions
Is Alloy or Midi Health better?
Alloy scores higher on our rubric (10.0 vs 8.3 out of 10). That reflects price transparency, labs, prescribers, availability and cancellation terms, not clinical outcomes. Alloy: Cash-pay women who want FDA-approved estradiol and progesterone prescribed by a physician through messaging, with prices visible up front. Midi Health: Women with commercial PPO insurance seeking menopause or perimenopause care, including hormone therapy, through video visits.
Which is cheaper, Alloy or Midi Health?
Alloy starts at $49 one-time consult + estradiol pill from $39.99/mo. Midi Health starts at $250 first visit self-pay ($150 follow-ups); insurance copays vary. Compare what each price includes, especially labs and medication.
Do Alloy and Midi Health include lab work?
Alloy: not needed. Midi Health: unconfirmed.
Which is easier to cancel?
Alloy: Terms: cancel via account dashboard or by emailing support@myalloy.com at least 7 days before the end of the current subscription period; shipments can be paused or cancelled in the account 5 business days before processing. Consultation and subscription fees non-refundable; only the first shipment of each physical product is refundable within 30 days; dispensed prescriptions cannot be returned. Midi Health: No membership or subscription for visits (pay per visit). Midi's own patient-reviews page says to cancel or reschedule with at least 24 hours notice to avoid a cancellation fee (amount not stated); card-on-file policy lists cancellation fees as chargeable.